Alimony in India: Beyond the Gold Digger Narrative

"She's divorcing him just to demand a fortune."

It's a line that's been tossed around in countless debates, WhatsApp groups, and social media threads. But what does it really mean to ask for alimony? Is it unfair? Is it opportunistic? Or are we oversimplifying an issue deeply tied to societal inequities? Let's take a closer look at the reality behind alimony and maintenance in India.

Understanding Alimony in India

Alimony isn't about punishment or revenge. It's about ensuring financial stability post-divorce. India's marriage laws recognise that one spouse—often the woman—may have sacrificed her career, education, or financial independence to contribute to the household. In such cases, alimony ensures she doesn't face economic ruin.

Indian law distinguishes between maintenance (regular financial support during and after divorce proceedings) and alimony (a one-time settlement or periodic payments post-divorce). The amount isn't arbitrary; it depends on factors like income, assets, duration of marriage, and the spouse's ability to sustain themselves.

Yet, it's this system that faces growing criticism. Recent high-profile cases have reignited debates about whether women misuse alimony laws to exploit men. Let's consider a widely discussed example.

The Case of Atul Subhash

The tragic death of Atul Subhash has brought attention to the complexities of alimony disputes. Subhash alleged that his estranged wife and her family harassed him with multiple legal cases and exorbitant financial demands, including a significant increase in maintenance payments. He detailed his distress in a 24-page note and an 80-minute video before his death. This case has sparked discussions about the potential misuse of alimony laws and the need for a balanced approach that considers both parties' circumstances.

The Other Side: Women Left to Struggle

For every Atul Subhash, there are countless women whose stories go unheard. Consider the recent case of a domestic abuse survivor in Rajasthan. After enduring years of violence, she finally sought a divorce but was denied maintenance because her husband falsely claimed insolvency. Left with no income and two children to support, she's now fighting a drawn-out legal battle.

While some cases highlight potential abuses, it's crucial to recognise that divorce laws, including provisions for alimony, often serve as lifelines for individuals escaping abusive or neglectful marriages.

Such cases highlight the systemic challenges women face in securing their rights. Divorce laws, often painted as favouring women, are actually difficult to navigate. Many women lack the resources or legal knowledge to claim alimony, leaving them vulnerable.

For instance, the landmark Shah Bano case underscored the necessity of maintenance rights for divorced Muslim women, leading to significant legal reforms. Additionally, judgments like the one from the Madras High Court, which recognised the value of women's domestic contributions by granting them equal share in marital property, demonstrate the protective intent of these laws.

Why Draw Parallels to the Reservation System?

Critics of alimony often argue that it's unfair—"a handout for women who can't move on." But isn't this argument eerily similar to the opposition against India's reservation system?

Reservations exist to correct historical injustices. They provide opportunities to communities marginalized for generations, acknowledging that systemic inequities don't disappear overnight. Similarly, alimony recognizes that marriage—especially in India—often creates economic disparities.

When a woman sacrifices her career to build a home, she's making a choice that benefits the family but limits her earning potential. Post-divorce, she can't magically undo years of financial dependence. Alimony, like reservations, isn't about charity; it's about levelling the playing field.

So, Are Women Wrong to Ask?

Let's be honest. The system isn't perfect. Some cases may involve inflated demands or bad faith. But does that mean we vilify every woman who seeks alimony?

We're quick to label women as "gold diggers" without understanding the complexities of their situations. Divorce isn't easy. Asking for alimony is often a necessity, not greed. It's a means of survival in a society where women still earn less, own less, and have fewer financial opportunities than men.

The Need for Change

That said, there's room for improvement.

Transparency in Alimony Calculations: Courts need clearer guidelines to determine alimony amounts, reducing ambiguity and ensuring fairness.

Implementation of Gender-Neutral Laws: While women are the primary beneficiaries, men in vulnerable situations also have the right to claim alimony.

Stronger Enforcement: Women who are granted alimony often struggle to receive it due to non-compliance. The legal system must prioritize enforcement.

Let's Talk Before We Judge

As someone who believes in fairness, I'll admit there are flaws in the system. Certain demands may seem excessive, and some processes feel outdated. But the answer isn't to demonize women or dismiss the concept of alimony entirely. The answer lies in informed discussions.

Next time we hear about a woman asking for alimony, let's pause. Let's ask: What sacrifices did she make? What does she need to move forward? What does the law say? Because until we know all the facts, pointing fingers only adds to the noise—and none of us need more of that.

If you or somebody you know is struggling with something difficult and needs to get in touch withour expertt, consider reaching our Support and Engage verticals for affordable and inclusive help! Like our content? Please show us some support by sharing and up-voting!

Image Credits: Unsplash