
And why It Is Not as Noble as It Looks
Most of us, especially in South Asian cultures, have been taught from a very young age to be more generous, which shapes our understanding of what giving means. Society often praises this trait, but it can obscure our true motivations and self-awareness about why we give. Have we ever stopped to think if this is truly generosity? Why are people who are ‘givers’ the way they are?
When my clients tell me giving is easy and receiving feels difficult, or giving comes very naturally to them, I always wonder why. I wonder how this became a part of their identity and what factors might have played a role.
The Meaning Behind the ‘Giver Identity
A lot of the time, we want to be kind and generous, and it's a great quality to have. However, how do we know where generosity stops and this giving streak begins? When I started to observe, what stood out to me was how a couple of experiences shape us into this.
Many children may have grown up thinking love and acceptance come their way when they give.
When saying no or drawing boundaries is met with withdrawal of love, coldness or silent treatment
A fear that people might leave once they stop getting what we have to give
Fear of appearing selfish for not giving
Believing their needs come second or don't matter as much
Feeling the need to be the strong, dependable, or responsible one constantly
The Origin of Constant Giving
It gets easy to tell people to ‘stop doing it’, ‘just say no’, ‘you need better boundaries', etc. Most people do not actively choose to keep saying yes even when they want to say no. There is usually something hidden beneath the inability to do so. A lot of times, when children grow up in homes where the only way they found love or acceptance was by being good, not saying no, being agreeable, and not having any boundaries or tantrums, they may not be able just to stop one day. A lot of children grow up with adult responsibilities, worrying about their fighting parents, taking care of their younger siblings, ensuring everything is in order at home so as not to set people off, etc. Growing up amid uncertainty and unpredictable emotions can scare children into behaving well all the time, just to avoid adding to existing issues at home.
Several times, attachment wounds cause these children to live in a constant state of survival where they continue to appease people and be good by always giving, never saying no, never drawing boundaries, just to walk on the familiar path. The cultural expectations placed specifically on women in many scenarios, where they are expected to be more accommodating, forgiving, and self-sacrificing, reinforce the belief that continuous giving brings us safety and stability, often at the expense of self-awareness and boundaries. Constantly checking in on everyone without them reciprocating Feeling guilty for resting, choosing oneself or drawing boundaries Having resentments towards people while still saying yes Feeling invisible while carrying multiple burdens Struggling to ask for help or receive Feeling guilty or empty when people do not ask them for things This cycle does not stop here. Most of the time, people bear the brunt of this cost while remaining in the same loop. Again, recognising or making changes could feel very difficult. When givers start experiencing resentment, it is immediately followed by guilt or shame for feeling it. Though these resentments exist for a reason, they are usually trying to tell us something. Resentments could mean: You are overextending You need better boundaries, or they aren't being honoured You are going beyond your capacity The love or recognition you want to receive is coming at a cost to you. Healthy Giving Giver Identity Choice Obligation Can say no Feeling guilty saying no Giving within capacity Giving until exhausted Healthy reciprocity Secretly longs to be cared for too Identity is larger than helping Helping becomes identity The most common perception is that boundaries are rude. Boundaries need not be rude; they can still be kind and considerate. It's not just for one person, but for both. Healthy boundaries are essential to sustainable relationships. Here, both people have the opportunity to show love, care, and effort, which helps make the relationship more balanced rather than one-sided. Before you go, here are a few questions to gently sit with When was the last time you accepted help with feeling sorry or guilty? Do you give because you genuinely want to, or because not giving feels unsafe, or both? Who are you when you are not giving? Do you find it easy to receive, and are you surrounded by people who give? What would change if people embraced you saying no or drawing boundaries? If you'd like support on this journey, we are here to help. Image Credits: Pexels
When children are praised or loved only when they are good, and the moment they have normal human emotions like anger, stubbornness, sadness, they are immediately called bad. This may also lead to them wanting to avoid conflict, and even asking for help or saying no may feel like friction.
The Emotional CostRepeatedly giving, of course, also eventually leads to emotional exhaustion. This exhaustion can show up in many different ways. This exhaustion can look like:
Difference between Compassion and Self-Abandonment
Choosing Sustainability over Self-sacrificeWithout healthy boundaries, giving becomes more obligatory than a choice coming from a place of love. When we set healthy boundaries, we are not only helping ourselves but also letting those around us know what is and isn't okay.
If you find yourself constantly putting others first at the expense of your own well-being, it may be worth exploring the source of that pattern. Therapy can provide a safe space to understand these patterns, develop healthier boundaries, and build relationships in which care is mutual rather than one-side.