.jpg)
Are Getting Wrong About Mental Health
Writers Note:
This piece started from a simple observation: many workplaces now have mental health programmes, but a lot of people still don’t feel safe enough to use them. The support exists on paper. The hesitation lives in the culture.
We wrote this for World Mental Health Day because access is only one part of the story. The question“What will people think of me if I ask for help?” still shapes whether someone reaches out or keeps pushing through.
If this feels familiar, you’re not alone. And if you’re in a position to influence how work feels for others, we hope this gives you something useful to sit with.
It’s 9 o’clock at night, and you’re still at your desk. For the third time this week.
There’s a headache that started sometime after the second coffee. You haven’t eaten dinner. Your heart sinks when you know you’re going to be back here in under 12 hours. Your company does have a mental health programme. There was an email about it a few months ago. You vaguely remember something about free therapy sessions and a confidential helpline.
You’ve never used either.
A colleague once took a few days off because they were struggling. People talked about it for weeks afterwards. Nothing particularly cruel was said. It was there, though — that subtle undercurrent. A joke about how stressful the project apparently was. Your manager didn’t join in, but didn’t exactly shut it down either.
So when you finally log off, you take a paracetamol and decide you just need a good night’s sleep.
This is a fairly common problem with the way we talk about mental health at work. We tend to focus on whether support is available. For the person deciding whether to use that support, there is another question: what will people here think of me if I do?
You Can’t Fix Burnout With Benefits
Over the last few years, companies in India have added a lot more to their employee wellbeing programmes. EAPs, therapy partnerships, mental health leave, counselling helplines, mindfulness sessions and wellness workshops are no longer unusual. Particularly in larger organisations.
This is progress. People should have access to these things.
However, access can only do so much when the problem also stems from how work is organised.
Take an employee working late because their team is understaffed. Therapy may help them manage the stress, but it won’t change the workload waiting for them the next morning. Or consider a company that introduces a mental health day. The policy encourages it, but if your manager resents it, using it can still feel like a professional risk.
This is where some workplace wellbeing programmes fall short. They focus heavily on helping employees cope with work without spending enough time looking at the work they are being asked to cope with.
Why Employees Still Don’t Speak Up
One of the more revealing pieces of research came from Naukri in 2025.
It surveyed 19,650 professionals about taking time off for mental health. Only 28% said they would be comfortable explicitly telling their employer that mental health was the reason. 45% said they would record it as ordinary sick leave. Another 19% said they would avoid taking leave altogether, while 9% would give a different reason.
This is worth paying attention to because many employees are choosing to keep their mental health separate from their professional identity.
Office culture is built through small signals as much as formal policies. People notice which colleagues are considered dependable and which are considered difficult. They hear how managers speak about someone who has taken repeated leave. They see who gets praised for working late.
You don’t need to announce how being overworked is valued. If the person who is permanently available keeps getting rewarded for it, the team gets the message.
The same is true of mental health.
A company can tell employees that there is no stigma attached to asking for help. What happens to the first few people who actually ask will tell much more.
A Lot Of This Comes Down To Managers
It is easy to put workplace mental health under HR because HR usually manages the programmes. However, an employee's experience is more likely to be shaped by their manager.
Managers set deadlines. They respond when there’s too much on someone's plate. They also have influence over how comfortable a team feels.
This is where psychological safety becomes important. Can people speak honestly without worrying that they will be punished for it?
What managers can do is much more mundane, and probably more useful.
Managers also need to look at their own habits. A manager may send messages at 11 pm without expecting a reply. Their team may not know that. A leader may encourage breaks but never take leave themselves. That still sends a message about what commitment looks like.
These things are harder to put on a wellbeing calendar than a webinar. They are also much closer to the actual experience of work.
What Should Companies Change?
A useful place to start is by listening.
If employees keep raising the same issues - unrealistic deadlines, understaffing, poor boundaries or difficult managers - pay attention. These are wellbeing issues too. A resilience workshop won’t help much if nothing changes at work.
Companies can also be much clearer about confidentiality. Employees need to trust that using an EAP is genuinely confidential.
Manager training needs attention as well. It needs to go beyond a presentation on recognising signs of distress. Managers need practical training on what to do when someone is struggling. That includes handling leave, setting reasonable boundaries and knowing when professional support is needed.
Then there is the simplest test of all: look at what happens when somebody uses the policies you have created.
If employees have mental health leave but disguise it as sick leave, find out why. If an EAP has very low uptake, don't immediately assume nobody needs it.
A mental health benefit can give someone access to support they might not otherwise have had. That is valuable. However, it can't make an unhealthy workplace healthy on its own.
At iDare, we work with organisations through corporate mental health programmes and leadership training.
The focus isn’t only on the support available to employees, but also the culture they work in every day. If you're looking at this from the other side and want to build a healthier workplace, you can speak to iDare about corporate mental health support.
Image Credits: UnSplash